SmogRank / History / July 2023

Most polluted cities, July 2023

2,381 cities ranked by their average PM2.5 over the 31 days; the worst was Coyhaique, Chile, at 103.9 µg/m³. A city needs measurements on 70% of the days to be ranked.

OpenAQ's archive, where our readings come from, has almost none for one of these days. Cities in the United States and Europe have it from the EPA's and the European Environment Agency's own records of the same monitors; elsewhere a city's average is over its other days. Why.

Canada: no city measured on Jul 14, compared with about 107 on the days around it. Japan: no city measured on Jul 27, compared with about 253 on the days around it. Most of their monitors have no readings for those days in our history: cities in Canada and Japan are averaged over their other days. Why.

Bad-air episodes during July 2023. All episodes.

← Coyhaique 103.9 µg/m³ 100 µg/m³0
Every city ranked for July 2023, one column each, worst on the left and cleanest on the right; height is PM2.5 in µg/m³. Point at it to read a city; tap to open it.
  1. =1994SondershausenThuringia, Germany
    29 US AQI
  2. =1994HildesheimLower Saxony, Germany
    29 US AQI
  3. =1994HeidelbergBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    29 US AQI
  4. =1994GlashüttenHesse, Germany
    29 US AQI
  5. =1994AalenBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    29 US AQI
  6. =1994RambouilletÎle-de-France, France
    29 US AQI
  7. =1994MoulinsAuvergne-Rhône-Alpes, France
    29 US AQI
  8. =1994FréjusProvence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur, France
    29 US AQI
  9. =1994ÉpernayGrand Est, France
    29 US AQI
  10. =1994CreilHauts-de-France, France
    29 US AQI
  11. =1994ChâteaurouxCentre-Val de Loire, France
    29 US AQI
  12. =1994Casas AdobesArizona, United States
    29 US AQI
  13. =1994CondaIdaho, United States
    29 US AQI
  14. =1994Grants PassOregon, United States
    29 US AQI
  15. =1994ShorelineWashington, United States
    29 US AQI
  16. =1994Mount PearlNewfoundland and Labrador, Canada
    29 US AQI
  17. =1994Strawberry HillBritish Columbia, Canada
    29 US AQI
  18. =2018Santiago do CacémSetúbal, Portugal
    29 US AQI
  19. =2018San Sebastián de la GomeraCanary Islands, Spain
    29 US AQI
  20. =2018YorkEngland, United Kingdom
    29 US AQI
  21. =2018SwanseaWales, United Kingdom
    29 US AQI
  22. =2018NorthamptonEngland, United Kingdom
    29 US AQI
  23. =2018ManchesterEngland, United Kingdom
    29 US AQI
  24. =2018DagenhamEngland, United Kingdom
    29 US AQI
  25. =2018FreistadtUpper Austria, Austria
    29 US AQI
  26. =2018GärtringenBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    29 US AQI
  27. =2018FürthHesse, Germany
    29 US AQI
  28. =2018Eggenstein-LeopoldshafenBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    29 US AQI
  29. =2018VesoulBourgogne-Franche-Comté, France
    29 US AQI
  30. =2018MontargisCentre-Val de Loire, France
    29 US AQI
  31. =2018DreuxCentre-Val de Loire, France
    29 US AQI
  32. =2018BrestBrittany, France
    29 US AQI
  33. =2018MossØstfold, Norway
    29 US AQI
  34. =2018CayenneGuyane, French Guiana
    29 US AQI
  35. =2018GilroyCalifornia, United States
    29 US AQI
  36. =2018PendletonOregon, United States
    29 US AQI
  37. =2018Rock SpringsWyoming, United States
    29 US AQI
  38. =2018Corner BrookNewfoundland and Labrador, Canada
    29 US AQI
  39. =2018Grand Falls-WindsorNewfoundland and Labrador, Canada
    29 US AQI
  40. =2040VentspilsVentspils, Latvia
    28 US AQI
  41. =2040VantaaUusimaa, Finland
    28 US AQI
  42. =2040Gold CoastQueensland, Australia
    28 US AQI
  43. =2040BexleyEngland, United Kingdom
    28 US AQI
  44. =2040BeduidoAveiro, Portugal
    28 US AQI
  45. =2040SpijkenisseSouth Holland, The Netherlands
    28 US AQI
  46. =2040SteyrUpper Austria, Austria
    28 US AQI
  47. =2040WieslochBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    28 US AQI
  48. =2040PforzheimBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    28 US AQI
  49. =2040HannoverLower Saxony, Germany
    28 US AQI
  50. =2040Bad BelzigBrandenburg, Germany
    28 US AQI
  51. =2040ToursCentre-Val de Loire, France
    28 US AQI
  52. =2040OlivetCentre-Val de Loire, France
    28 US AQI
  53. =2040HaguenauGrand Est, France
    28 US AQI
  54. =2040AurillacAuvergne-Rhône-Alpes, France
    28 US AQI
  55. =2040ArrasHauts-de-France, France
    28 US AQI
  56. =2040ArteixoGalicia, Spain
    28 US AQI
  57. =2040MesquiteNevada, United States
    28 US AQI
  58. =2040PriceUtah, United States
    28 US AQI
  59. =2040PocatelloIdaho, United States
    28 US AQI
  60. =2040AbbotsfordBritish Columbia, Canada
    28 US AQI
  61. =2040Val-de-ReuilNormandy, France
    28 US AQI
  62. =2062FunchalMadeira, Portugal
    28 US AQI
  63. =2062SaguntoValencia, Spain
    28 US AQI
  64. =2062NewportWales, United Kingdom
    28 US AQI
  65. =2062UtrechtUtrecht, The Netherlands
    28 US AQI
  66. =2062RidderkerkSouth Holland, The Netherlands
    28 US AQI
  67. =2062MaassluisSouth Holland, The Netherlands
    28 US AQI
  68. =2062Zell am SeeSalzburg, Austria
    28 US AQI
  69. =2062SchwerteNorth Rhine-Westphalia, Germany
    28 US AQI
  70. =2062RintelnLower Saxony, Germany
    28 US AQI
  71. =2062Neuhaus am RennwegThuringia, Germany
    28 US AQI
  72. =2062NetphenNorth Rhine-Westphalia, Germany
    28 US AQI
  73. =2062MalchowMecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany
    28 US AQI
  74. =2062LingenLower Saxony, Germany
    28 US AQI
  75. =2062GersfeldHesse, Germany
    28 US AQI
  76. =2062Saint-Étienne-de-MontlucPays de la Loire, France
    28 US AQI
  77. =2062NiortNew Aquitaine, France
    28 US AQI
  78. =2062LimogesNew Aquitaine, France
    28 US AQI
  79. =2062La Roche-sur-YonPays de la Loire, France
    28 US AQI
  80. =2062Joué-lès-ToursCentre-Val de Loire, France
    28 US AQI
  81. =2062CaenNormandy, France
    28 US AQI
  82. =2062BourgesCentre-Val de Loire, France
    28 US AQI
  83. =2062BeauvaisHauts-de-France, France
    28 US AQI
  84. =2062AlençonNormandy, France
    28 US AQI
  85. =2062ChrastavaLiberec Region, Czechia
    28 US AQI
  86. =2062StrømmenAkershus, Norway
    28 US AQI
  87. =2062PorsgrunnTelemark, Norway
    28 US AQI
  88. =2062San Luis ObispoCalifornia, United States
    28 US AQI
  89. =2062Spanish SpringsNevada, United States
    28 US AQI
  90. =2062OntarioOregon, United States
    28 US AQI
  91. =2091LiepājaLiepaja, Latvia
    27 US AQI
  92. =2091AyrQueensland, Australia
    27 US AQI
  93. =2091AmoraSetúbal, Portugal
    27 US AQI
  94. =2091TumbaStockholm, Sweden
    27 US AQI
  95. =2091SundsvallVästernorrland, Sweden
    27 US AQI
  96. =2091Villingen-SchwenningenBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    27 US AQI
  97. =2091StralsundMecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany
    27 US AQI
  98. =2091SalzgitterLower Saxony, Germany
    27 US AQI
  99. =2091LüchowLower Saxony, Germany
    27 US AQI
  100. =2091BraunschweigLower Saxony, Germany
    27 US AQI
  101. =2091PoitiersNew Aquitaine, France
    27 US AQI
  102. =2091NantesPays de la Loire, France
    27 US AQI
  103. =2091ForbachGrand Est, France
    27 US AQI
  104. =2091ÉvreuxNormandy, France
    27 US AQI
  105. =2091ChartresCentre-Val de Loire, France
    27 US AQI
  106. =2091Bourg-en-BresseAuvergne-Rhône-Alpes, France
    27 US AQI
  107. =2091NarónGalicia, Spain
    27 US AQI
  108. =2091KourouGuyane, French Guiana
    27 US AQI
  109. =2091ReykjavíkCapital Region, Iceland
    27 US AQI
  110. =2091Green ValleyArizona, United States
    27 US AQI
  111. =2091SebastopolCalifornia, United States
    27 US AQI
  112. =2091MoscowIdaho, United States
    27 US AQI
  113. =2091ChehalisWashington, United States
    27 US AQI
  114. =2091BurnabyBritish Columbia, Canada
    27 US AQI
  115. =2091Port CoquitlamBritish Columbia, Canada
    27 US AQI
  116. =2116MaspalomasCanary Islands, Spain
    27 US AQI
  117. =2116WarringtonEngland, United Kingdom
    27 US AQI
  118. =2116SchiedamSouth Holland, The Netherlands
    27 US AQI
  119. =2116HeerlenLimburg, The Netherlands
    27 US AQI
  120. =2116Waldfischbach-BurgalbenRheinland-Pfalz, Germany
    27 US AQI
  121. =2116MontbéliardBourgogne-Franche-Comté, France
    27 US AQI
  122. =2116BloisCentre-Val de Loire, France
    27 US AQI
  123. =2116CanbyOregon, United States
    27 US AQI
  124. =2116The DallesOregon, United States
    27 US AQI
  125. =2116EllensburgWashington, United States
    27 US AQI
  126. =2116SheltonWashington, United States
    27 US AQI
  127. =2116WenatcheeWashington, United States
    27 US AQI
  128. =2116LangfordBritish Columbia, Canada
    27 US AQI
  129. =2116West VancouverBritish Columbia, Canada
    27 US AQI
  130. =2130HelsinkiUusimaa, Finland
    26 US AQI
  131. =2130NorwichEngland, United Kingdom
    26 US AQI
  132. =2130HartlepoolEngland, United Kingdom
    26 US AQI
  133. =2130TournaiWallonia, Belgium
    26 US AQI
  134. =2130WilhelmshavenLower Saxony, Germany
    26 US AQI
  135. =2130Baden-BadenBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    26 US AQI
  136. =2130Saint-DizierGrand Est, France
    26 US AQI
  137. =2130SilvertonOregon, United States
    26 US AQI
  138. =2130StaytonOregon, United States
    26 US AQI
  139. =2130RidgefieldWashington, United States
    26 US AQI
  140. =2130LhokaTibet, China
    26 US AQI
  141. =2141Saint-DenisReunion, Reunion
    26 US AQI
  142. =2141Stoke-on-TrentEngland, United Kingdom
    26 US AQI
  143. =2141LeedsEngland, United Kingdom
    26 US AQI
  144. =2141BrightlingseaEngland, United Kingdom
    26 US AQI
  145. =2141KüssnachtSchwyz, Switzerland
    26 US AQI
  146. =2141VisbyGotland, Sweden
    26 US AQI
  147. =2141BredaNorth Brabant, The Netherlands
    26 US AQI
  148. =2141TrochtelfingenBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    26 US AQI
  149. =2141EnniscorthyLeinster, Ireland
    26 US AQI
  150. =2141GuitirizGalicia, Spain
    26 US AQI
  151. =2141MarystownNewfoundland and Labrador, Canada
    26 US AQI
  152. =2141Tri-CitiesWashington, United States
    26 US AQI
  153. =2153Southend-on-SeaEngland, United Kingdom
    25 US AQI
  154. =2153GoslarLower Saxony, Germany
    25 US AQI
  155. =2153CorkMunster, Ireland
    25 US AQI
  156. =2153LunévilleGrand Est, France
    25 US AQI
  157. =2153ZarautzBasque Country, Spain
    25 US AQI
  158. =2153LeónCastille and León, Spain
    25 US AQI
  159. =2153Mo i RanaNordland, Norway
    25 US AQI
  160. =2153GuadalupeCalifornia, United States
    25 US AQI
  161. =2153RivertonWyoming, United States
    25 US AQI
  162. =2153LangleyBritish Columbia, Canada
    25 US AQI
  163. =2163BlackwaterQueensland, Australia
    24 US AQI
  164. =2163BelfastNorthern Ireland, United Kingdom
    24 US AQI
  165. =2163La Ferté-MacéNormandy, France
    24 US AQI
  166. =2163Baume-les-DamesBourgogne-Franche-Comté, France
    24 US AQI
  167. =2163GreshamOregon, United States
    24 US AQI
  168. =2163PortlandOregon, United States
    24 US AQI
  169. =2163BellinghamWashington, United States
    24 US AQI
  170. =2163Mount VernonWashington, United States
    24 US AQI
  171. =2163North BendWashington, United States
    24 US AQI
  172. =2163NyingchiTibet, China
    24 US AQI
  173. =2173PoriSatakunta, Finland
    24 US AQI
  174. =2173SheffieldEngland, United Kingdom
    24 US AQI
  175. =2173BirminghamEngland, United Kingdom
    24 US AQI
  176. =2173TroyesGrand Est, France
    24 US AQI
  177. =2173Lons-le-SaunierBourgogne-Franche-Comté, France
    24 US AQI
  178. =2173KristiansandAgder, Norway
    24 US AQI
  179. =2173FredrikstadØstfold, Norway
    24 US AQI
  180. =2173PrestonIdaho, United States
    24 US AQI
  181. =2173BellevueWashington, United States
    24 US AQI
  182. =2173Port AngelesWashington, United States
    24 US AQI
  183. =2173HonoluluHawaii, United States
    24 US AQI
  184. =2173Münstertal/SchwarzwaldBaden-Wurttemberg, Germany
    24 US AQI
  185. =2173Makakilo / Kapolei / Honokai HaleHawaii, United States
    24 US AQI
  186. =2173HarewoodBritish Columbia, Canada
    24 US AQI
  187. =2187TeldeCanary Islands, Spain
    23 US AQI
  188. =2187PrestonEngland, United Kingdom
    23 US AQI
  189. =2187Newcastle upon TyneEngland, United Kingdom
    23 US AQI
  190. =2187Kingston upon HullEngland, United Kingdom
    23 US AQI
  191. =2187ImminghamEngland, United Kingdom
    23 US AQI
  192. =2187HonitonEngland, United Kingdom
    23 US AQI
  193. =2187AndoverEngland, United Kingdom
    23 US AQI
  194. =2187MalmöSkåne, Sweden
    23 US AQI
  195. =2187Le TraitNormandy, France
    23 US AQI
  196. =2187OsloOslo, Norway
    23 US AQI
  197. =2187RabinalBaja Verapaz, Guatemala
    23 US AQI
  198. =2187Guatemala CityGuatemala, Guatemala
    23 US AQI
  199. =2187HillsboroOregon, United States
    23 US AQI
  200. =2187Sweet HomeOregon, United States
    23 US AQI

What stands behind each figure: Monitors 3 km+ apart One monitor location Low-cost sensors About these marks

Good0–50
Moderate51–100
Unhealthy for sensitive groups101–150
Unhealthy151–200
Very unhealthy201–300
Hazardous301+

The US EPA's Air Quality Index for PM2.5 (2024 breakpoints). Show values as: · US AQI · · · · · · · . About the scales

Not covered: Iran's government monitoring network, which publishes live readings only on its own website. Its website doesn't answer requests from outside the country, so we can't read it. Most cities there are missing from this board, not clean. Why.

Most polluted countries, July 2023

46 countries with 3 or more ranked cities, ranked by their typical city: the median of each one's ranked cities' means, July 2023, not the whole country.

Not ranked, fewer than 3 cities: Algeria, Andorra, Azerbaijan, Bangladesh, Belize, French Guiana, Georgia, Guadeloupe, Guatemala, Guinea, Iceland, Indonesia, Jordan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Laos, Madagascar, Malaysia, Myanmar, Nepal, Nigeria, Qatar, Saint Martin, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Sri Lanka, Tajikistan, Turkey, Uzbekistan and Vietnam.

Each tick is a ranked city on a log scale in µg/m³, coloured by its band; the tall bar is the median.

CountryCitiesTypical city (median)Every city, µg/m³Worst city
Chile4440.8 44 cities from 17.9 to 103.9 µg/m³, the typical one 40.8Worst: Coyhaique 103.9 µg/m³
Pakistan low-cost sensors432.6 4 cities from 22.9 to 43.0 µg/m³, the typical one 32.6Worst: Lahore 43.0 µg/m³
Kuwait529.4 5 cities from 26.3 to 38.1 µg/m³, the typical one 29.4Worst: Al Farwānīyah 38.1 µg/m³
Bosnia and Herzegovina323.6 3 cities from 11.5 to 27.8 µg/m³, the typical one 23.6Worst: Sarajevo 27.8 µg/m³
Malta416.8 4 cities from 14.0 to 18.9 µg/m³, the typical one 16.8Worst: Mosta 18.9 µg/m³
China44315.8 443 cities from 3.7 to 78.2 µg/m³, the typical one 15.8Worst: Gujangbagh 78.2 µg/m³
Martinique314.6 3 cities from 13.3 to 14.8 µg/m³, the typical one 14.6Worst: Le Robert 14.8 µg/m³
Brazil3514.5 35 cities from 3.5 to 28.6 µg/m³, the typical one 14.5Worst: Açailândia 28.6 µg/m³
Greece1513.8 15 cities from 10.4 to 22.7 µg/m³, the typical one 13.8Worst: Asprópyrgos 22.7 µg/m³
Mexico1213.5 12 cities from 7.7 to 19.6 µg/m³, the typical one 13.5Worst: Ciudad Juárez 19.6 µg/m³
Thailand1013.3 10 cities from 10.1 to 16.6 µg/m³, the typical one 13.3Worst: Nong Khaem 16.6 µg/m³
Italy3012.9 30 cities from 7.9 to 16.1 µg/m³, the typical one 12.9Worst: Marigliano 16.1 µg/m³
India512.8 5 cities from 6.3 to 27.4 µg/m³, the typical one 12.8Worst: Delhi 27.4 µg/m³
Serbia311.9 3 cities from 8.5 to 12.4 µg/m³, the typical one 11.9Worst: Niš 12.4 µg/m³
Romania1311.7 13 cities from 7.1 to 14.8 µg/m³, the typical one 11.7Worst: Cernica 14.8 µg/m³
Slovakia3911.4 39 cities from 8.2 to 16.8 µg/m³, the typical one 11.4Worst: Čaňa 16.8 µg/m³
North Macedonia1111.4 11 cities from 8.1 to 15.0 µg/m³, the typical one 11.4Worst: Bitola 15.0 µg/m³
United States67610.6 676 cities from 2.2 to 19.4 µg/m³, the typical one 10.6Worst: Fontana 19.4 µg/m³
Canada9810.6 98 cities from 1.4 to 38.5 µg/m³, the typical one 10.6Worst: Fort McMurray 38.5 µg/m³
Bulgaria low-cost sensors69.7 6 cities from 8.2 to 12.9 µg/m³, the typical one 9.7Worst: Ruse 12.9 µg/m³
Hungary79.5 7 cities from 7.8 to 10.3 µg/m³, the typical one 9.5Worst: Szeged 10.3 µg/m³
Albania39.5 3 cities from 8.4 to 13.9 µg/m³, the typical one 9.5Worst: Fier 13.9 µg/m³
Czechia359.4 35 cities from 5.0 to 11.7 µg/m³, the typical one 9.4Worst: Havířov 11.7 µg/m³
Poland629.0 62 cities from 2.3 to 14.0 µg/m³, the typical one 9.0Worst: Lublin 14.0 µg/m³
Kosovo78.9 7 cities from 7.5 to 17.2 µg/m³, the typical one 8.9Worst: Pristina 17.2 µg/m³
Croatia58.7 5 cities from 7.2 to 10.7 µg/m³, the typical one 8.7Worst: Koprivnica 10.7 µg/m³
Spain1118.0 111 cities from 1.9 to 18.1 µg/m³, the typical one 8.0Worst: Albacete 18.1 µg/m³
Slovenia108.0 10 cities from 7.2 to 8.5 µg/m³, the typical one 8.0Worst: Kranj 8.5 µg/m³
Luxembourg37.8 3 cities from 7.2 to 8.6 µg/m³, the typical one 7.8Worst: Esch-sur-Alzette 8.6 µg/m³
Colombia37.5 3 cities from 6.9 to 14.4 µg/m³, the typical one 7.5Worst: Funza 14.4 µg/m³
Lithuania47.3 4 cities from 3.5 to 8.6 µg/m³, the typical one 7.3Worst: Kaunas 8.6 µg/m³
Australia447.1 44 cities from 3.5 to 17.5 µg/m³, the typical one 7.1Worst: Armidale 17.5 µg/m³
Austria336.5 33 cities from 5.0 to 9.4 µg/m³, the typical one 6.5Worst: Graz 9.4 µg/m³
Switzerland86.3 8 cities from 4.6 to 7.8 µg/m³, the typical one 6.3Worst: Giubiasco 7.8 µg/m³
Germany1906.1 190 cities from 3.6 to 10.2 µg/m³, the typical one 6.1Worst: Weiden 10.2 µg/m³
Belgium406.0 40 cities from 1.4 to 7.8 µg/m³, the typical one 6.0Worst: Meulebeke 7.8 µg/m³
France1455.8 145 cities from 2.7 to 11.5 µg/m³, the typical one 5.8Worst: Nice 11.5 µg/m³
The Netherlands235.4 23 cities from 3.9 to 8.0 µg/m³, the typical one 5.4Worst: Waalre 8.0 µg/m³
Latvia45.4 4 cities from 4.9 to 5.9 µg/m³, the typical one 5.4Worst: Rēzekne 5.9 µg/m³
Ireland34.5 3 cities from 3.7 to 4.6 µg/m³, the typical one 4.5Worst: Enniscorthy 4.6 µg/m³
United Kingdom744.2 74 cities from 2.5 to 8.2 µg/m³, the typical one 4.2Worst: Cwmafan 8.2 µg/m³
Norway174.1 17 cities from 2.8 to 6.1 µg/m³, the typical one 4.1Worst: Sarpsborg 6.1 µg/m³
Reunion34.0 3 cities from 4.0 to 4.6 µg/m³, the typical one 4.0Worst: Saint-Denis 4.6 µg/m³
Sweden183.9 18 cities from 3.2 to 6.5 µg/m³, the typical one 3.9Worst: Onsala 6.5 µg/m³
Finland143.8 14 cities from 2.4 to 5.1 µg/m³, the typical one 3.8Worst: Vantaa 5.1 µg/m³
Portugal193.6 19 cities from 1.6 to 9.5 µg/m³, the typical one 3.6Worst: Vieira de Leiria 9.5 µg/m³

Tagged low-cost sensors: more than half of the country's ranked cities are measured by low-cost sensors only, with no reference monitor in the city, so its typical city rests mostly on them.

The same board by continent, July 2023: Asia · Europe · Africa · North America · South America · Oceania.

Use this board

SmogRank, most polluted cities by mean PM2.5 (µg/m³), July 2023: each city's mean of its daily means, cities measured on 22 or more of the 31 days. Monitor data from national networks via OpenAQ and the publishers listed at smogrank.com/sources. smogrank.com/history/2023-07 (accessed 17 Nov 2026). Some values from Sensor.Community, ODbL. Some readings from Environment Public Authority, Kuwait; Uzhydromet (Uzbekistan's Hydrometeorological Service); Vietnam's government monitors; Department of Environment, Nepal; RMCAB (Secretaría Distrital de Ambiente, Bogotá); Aurassure; Umhverfisstofnun (Environment Agency of Iceland), no reuse terms published. Countries: ranked by their typical city, the median of their ranked cities' means on this board, from the same monitor data; 46 countries with 3 or more ranked cities. Most of their ranked cities on low-cost sensors, with no reference monitor in the city: Pakistan and Bulgaria.

Download top 10 (PNG)

You're welcome to reuse a single chart, image or figure with this citation and a link. Terms. Raw monitor readings in bulk are published by OpenAQ, under each provider's licence.